Minutes
Ordinary Council Meeting
24 October 2024, 7:00 PM
All minutes are subject to confirmation at a subsequent
meeting and may be amended by resolution at that meeting.
PRESENT: Councillor Southwood (Mayor), Councillor Bennison, Councillor Bryla, Councillor Flood, Councillor Greenwell, Councillor Kennedy, Councillor Little, Councillor Roenfeldt and Councillor Taylor.
ALSO PRESENT: General Manager, Director - Corporate Services and Strategy, Director - Planning and Sustainability, Director - Community and Culture, Director - Open Spaces and Infrastructure, Executive Officer to the GM and Minute Taker.
DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST:
Councillor Bennison declared a non-pecuniary interest that is significant in relation to the agenda item 7 – Proposed Sale of Drainage Reserve - Morrice Street and Tambourine Bay Road, as a tenant from his office lives in that street. Therefore Councillor Bennison will vacate the Chamber and not debate or vote on this matter.
Councillor Roenfeldt declared a non-pecuniary, non-significant interest in relation to the agenda item 7 – Proposed Sale of Drainage Reserve - Morrice Street and Tambourine Bay Road, due to having a Labor colleague who could financially benefit from any action on this agenda item. Therefore Councillor Roenfeldt will vacate the Chamber and not debate or vote on the matter.
Councillor Little declared a non-pecuniary, non-significant interest in relation to the agenda item 7 – Proposed Sale of Drainage Reserve - Morrice Street and Tambourine Bay Road, due to having a Labor colleague who could financially benefit from any action on this agenda item. Therefore Councillor Little will vacate the Chamber and not debate or vote on the matter.
Councillor Greenwell declared a non-pecuniary, non-significant pecuniary interest in relation to the agenda item 5 – Notice of Motion – Blackman Park Masterplan, due to Blackman Park being a place where she conducts business on occasion. As Councillor Greenwell does not believe this will impact her judgement on this matter, she will remain in the Chamber and will debate and vote on the matter.
Councillor Taylor declared a non-pecuniary, non-significant interest in relation to the agenda item 4 – Notice of Motion – Affordable Council Run Childcare, due to being employed by the largest private childcare operator in St Leonards. Councillor Taylor advised that at this stage he has no knowledge of them having interest to operate or purchase additional centres. Therefore Councillor Taylor will remain in the Chamber and debate and vote on the matter.
During the meeting, Councillor Bennison declared a conflict of interest regarding item 14 – Councillor representation on Council Advisory Committees and external organisations, as he is Treasurer of Lane Cove historical society. Therefore Councillor Bennison will vacate the Chamber and not debate or vote on Councillor membership of that committee.
Apologies
Nil
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF COUNTRY
The Mayor gave an acknowledgement of Country.
Minute of Silence for Reflection or Prayer
The Mayor gave notice of a minute of silence for reflection or prayer.
WEBCASTING OF COUNCIL MEETING
The Mayor advised those present that the Meeting was being webcast.
Online
1. Audrey Nicoloso of Lane Cove North, in relation to Item 2, Notice of Motion - Lane Cove North Neighbourhood Shops,
2. Daphne Chiang of St Leonards, in relation to the closure of Canberra Avenue and Newlands Park (Item 3), St Leonards,
3. Darvan Sinnetamby of Lane Cove, in relation to Item 8, Office of Local Government NSW - Councillor Conduct and Meeting Practices Discussion Paper and Item 15, Council Snapshot August and September 2024,
4. Vini Japiassu of Lane Cove North, in relation to Traffic Management plan for Mowbray precinct,
In Person
5. Bella Garton of Greenwich Cove, in relation to the Great Greenwich Reef,
6. Margaret Curley of Northwood, representing the Northwood Action Group, in relation to Bob Campbell Oval,
7. Simon Lake of Lane Cove North, in relation to clarification of timing of 14 Gay Street classification to rezone the entire site to C2 - Environmental Conservation in the next general LEP update,
8. Kevin Johnson of Pymble, CEO of Northern Suburbs Football Association, in relation to Item 5, Notice of Motion - Blackman Park Master Plan,
9. James Hansen of Lane Cove North, in relation to Item 2, Notice of Motion - Lane Cove North Neighbourhood Shops,
10. Jason Grinnell of Greenwich, in relation to Home charging for electric vehicles,
11. Dr Liz Gill of Greenwich, in relation to the work being conducted to support the upgrade of Greenwich wharf and upgrade of electrical supply, and the public liability issue it is creating on our local footpaths and road and other issues related to the works that are outside of the works area,
12. Tracy Ellis of St Leonards, in relation to Item 3, Notice of Motion - Progression of Expanded Newlands Park Masterplan, Including Elements Such as a Water Play Park,
13. Ruth Neumann of Lane Cove Bushland and Conservation Society, in relation to Item 5, Notice of Motion - Blackman Park Master Plan, Item 14 Councillor Representation on Council Advisory Committees and External Organisations for 2024-25 and general bushland,
14. Jacky Barker of Lane Cove, in relation to Councillor Conduct Framework and public access to council briefings, and also Thank you to Lane Cove Rotary and Lane Cove Council for Lane Cove Festival,
15. Michael Stojankovic of Lane Cove, President of Lane Cove Football Club, in relation to in relation to Item 5, Notice of Motion - Blackman Park Master Plan,
16. Kevin Garrington of Lane Cove, board member of Lane Cove Football Club, in relation to Item 5, Notice of Motion - Blackman Park Master Plan,
17. Penny Mabbutt of Greenwich, in relation to the Viva energy project, expansion of hard spaces in Duntroon Ave, and review of viability of financial projects,
18. Jenny Schneller of Northwood, in relation to item 4, Council run childcare, Item 3, Newlands Park, and Bob Campbell Oval,
19. Glenn Poynton of Lane Cove, regarding Item 5, Notice of Motion - Blackman Park Master Plan, and growth in AFL participation,
20. Anita Thommesen of Lane Cove, regarding Council rates, recognition on plaques, adult gym in Coxs Lane park, and subsidies for electrical vehicles and solar panels.
Councillor Kennedy left the meeting at 7.17pm and returned at 7.20pm.
WRITTEN SUBMISSIONS
Twenty two (22) written submissions were received, those being from;
1. Sharon Coley of the St Leonards Strata Community Group, in relation to Item 3, Notice of Motion - Progression of Expanded Newlands Park Masterplan, Including Elements Such as a Water Play Park, and
2. Shauna Forrest-President on behalf of the LCBCS Executive and members, in relation to Item 5, Notice of Motion - Blackman Park Master Plan and Item 14 - Councillor Representation on Council Advisory Committees and External Organisations for 2024-25,
3. Benjamin Noel Bernardo of Lane Cove North, in relation to Item 2, Notice of Motion - Lane Cove North Neighbourhood Shops,
4. Darren Wondal and Shirley Huang of Lane Cove North, in relation to Item 2, Notice of Motion - Lane Cove North Neighbourhood Shops
5. Megan Anderson of Lane Cove North, in relation to Item 2, Notice of Motion - Lane Cove North Neighbourhood Shops,
6. Yvette Stening of Lane Cove North, in relation to Item 2, Notice of Motion - Lane Cove North Neighbourhood Shops,
7. Joel Lee of Lane Cove North, in relation to Item 2, Notice of Motion - Lane Cove North Neighbourhood Shops,
8. Audrey Nicoloso of Lane Cove North, in relation to Item 2, Notice of Motion - Lane Cove North Neighbourhood Shops,
9. Chris Hall of Lane Cove North, in relation to Item 2, Notice of Motion - Lane Cove North Neighbourhood Shops,
10. Gerard O’Brien of Lane Cove North, in relation to Item 2, Notice of Motion - Lane Cove North Neighbourhood Shops,
11. Ezgi Isler of Lane Cove North, in relation to Item 2, Notice of Motion - Lane Cove North Neighbourhood Shops,
12. Anna MacDonald of Lane Cove North, in relation to Item 2, Notice of Motion - Lane Cove North Neighbourhood Shops,
13. Vaibhav Mehrotra of Lane Cove North, in relation to Item 2, Notice of Motion - Lane Cove North Neighbourhood Shops,
14. Greg Andresen, Kylie Innocente, Sarah Barratt and Justin Barratt of Lane Cove, in relation to Item 7 - Proposed Sale of Drainage Reserve - Morrice Street and Tambourine Bay Road - Final Report,
15. Melika Mokhtari & Christopher Mooney of Lane Cove, in relation to Item 7 – Proposed Sale of Drainage Reserve - Morrice Street and Tambourine Bay Road - Final Report,
16. Mitch Whitehall of Lane Cove, in relation to River Road SUP upgrade,
17. Michael Been of St Leonards in relation to Item 3, Notice of Motion - Progression of Expanded Newlands Park Masterplan, Including Elements Such as a Water Play Park,
18. Cassandra Brill & William Northam of Lane Cove, in relation to Item 7 – Proposed Sale of Drainage Reserve - Morrice Street and Tambourine Bay Road - Final Report,
19. Lane Cove Football Club, in relation to Item 5, Notice of Motion - Blackman Park Master Plan,
20. Frances Vissel of Lane Cove, in relation to Item 14, Councillor Representation on Council Advisory Committees and External Organisations For 2024-25,
21. Peter Stening of Lane Cove North, in relation to Item 2, Notice of Motion - Lane Cove North Neighbourhood Shops.
22. Ajaya Jayarao of Northwood, in relation to congratulating the elected Councillors and elected Mayor and Deputy Mayor.
Notices of Motion
|
A Motion was moved by Councillor Flood and seconded by Councillor Kennedy that Council: 1. Seek independent advice on the applicability of competitive neutrality principles to the operation of early childhood education facilities in the Lane Cove LGA, with a view to determining whether we are constrained by this principle, or if we have broader discretion. Funding for this written independent advice is to come from the Community and Culture Division legal budget. 2. Provide a report with this independent advice to a council workshop for further discussion on the capability of council to provide affordable childcare facilities for local families. 3. Table the independent advice at a council meeting for consideration. 4. Delay the release of the tender documents for the operation of the Early Childhood Centre at 13-19 Canberra Ave, St Leonards until points 1 - 3 have been completed.
|
|
An Amendment was moved by Councillor Bennison and seconded by Councillor Roenfeldt that Council: 1. Seek independent advice on the applicability of competitive neutrality principles to the operation of early childhood education facilities and other facilities for the potential exclusion of poker machines from Council based premises, pursuant to resolution no 187 dated 18 July 2024 in the Lane Cove LGA, with a view to determining whether we are constrained by this principle, or if we have broader discretion. Funding for this written independent advice is to come from the Community and Culture Division legal budget. 2. Provide a report with this independent advice to a council workshop for further discussion on the capability of council to provide affordable childcare facilities for local families. 3. Table the independent advice at a council meeting for consideration. 4. Delay the release of the tender documents for the operation of the Early Childhood Centre at 13-19 Canberra Ave, St Leonards until points 1 - 3 have been completed.
|
|
The Amendment was put to the vote and was declared lost. For the Motion were Councillors Bennison, Little, Roenfeldt and Taylor (Total 4). Against the Motion were Councillors Southwood, Bryla, Flood, Greenwell and Kennedy (Total 5). |
Councillor Bryla left the meeting at 8.30pm and returned at 8.34pm.
Councillors Bennison, Little and Roenfeldt left the meeting, the time being 08:51 PM
Proposed Sale of Drainage Reserve - Morrice Street and Tambourine Bay Road - Final Report |
|
RESOLVED on the motion moved by Councillor Flood and seconded by Councillor Greenwell that Council:- 1. receive and note the report; 2. proceed with sale of the Reserve land with those respondents who have agreed in-principle to Council’s terms at $2,000m2 plus administrative costs; 3. issue a Notice to any property owner occupying the reserve to vacate including structures and the re-establishment of boundary fences to their rightful location. Alternatively, an owner may enter a lease with Council (lessee shall absorb legal fees) to continue their occupancy of the Reserve; and 4. delegate Authority to the General Manager to execute all the relevant contractual documentation.
|
|
|
For the Motion were Councillors Southwood, Bryla, Flood, Greenwell, Kennedy and Taylor (Total 6). Against the Motion was Nil (Total 0). Absent were Councillors Bennison, Little and Roenfeldt (Total 3). |
Councillors Bennison, Little and Roenfeldt returned to the meeting, the time being 08:53 PM.
Office of Local Government NSW - Councillor Conduct and Meeting Practices Discussion Paper |
|
RESOLVED on the motion moved by Councillor Flood and seconded by Councillor Kennedy that Council:- 1. endorse the contents of this report as the basis for preparing a submission; 2. circulate a draft of the submission to councillors for further input ahead of a final report coming to the November meeting for endorsement; and 3. write to the OLG requesting an extension of time to allow the governing body time to endorse the submission in full. |
|
|
For the Motion were Councillors Southwood, Bennison, Bryla, Flood, Greenwell, Kennedy, Little, Roenfeldt and Taylor (Total 9). Against the Motion was Nil (Total 0). |
General Purpose Financial Statements for the year ended 30 June 2024 |
|
RESOLVED on the motion moved by Councillor Roenfeldt and seconded by Councillor Bryla that Council:- 1. adopt the General Purpose Financial Statements for the year ended 30 June 2024 (AT-1); 2. in accordance with Section 413(2)(c) of the Local Government Act, 1993, authorise the Mayor, one other Councillor, the General Manager and the Responsible Accounting Officer to sign the ‘Statement by Councillors and Management’ (AT-2) for the General Purpose Financial Statements and lodge them, together with the Auditor’s Reports, with the Office of Local Government by 31 October 2024; 3. note that the General Purpose Financial Statements will be placed on Council’s website for public comment; and 4. invite the Audit Office of NSW to attend the Council meeting of 21 November 2024 to present the Auditor’s Reports. |
|
|
For the Motion were Councillors Southwood, Bennison, Bryla, Flood, Greenwell, Kennedy, Little, Roenfeldt and Taylor (Total 9). Against the Motion was Nil (Total 0). |
Councillor Bennison left the meeting, the time being 09:25 PM.
RESOLVED on the motion moved by Councillor Southwood and seconded by Councillor Flood that the Councillor membership for Carisbrook Advisory Committee would be Councilllor Roenfeldt and Councillor Kennedy as alternate. |
|
|
For the Motion were Councillors Southwood, Bryla, Flood, Greenwell, Kennedy, Little, Roenfeldt and Taylor (Total 8). Against the Motion was Nil (Total 0). Absent Councillor Bennison (Total 1). |
Councillor Bennison returned to the meeting, the time being 09:27 PM
RESOLVED on the motion moved by Councillor Roenfeldt and seconded by Councillor Bennison that Council receive and note the report. |
|
|
For the Motion were Councillors Southwood, Bennison, Bryla, Flood, Greenwell, Kennedy, Little, Roenfeldt and Taylor (Total 9). Against the Motion was Nil (Total 0). |
The meeting closed at 9.28pm.
Confirmed at the Ordinary Council Meeting of 21 November 2024, at which meeting the signature herein is subscribed.
MAYOR
********* END OF MINUTES *********